The Book of Marble and Salt · Volume V
Vi
The Three Arguments
The Crown's partisans say that peace requires a force strong enough to end piracy, quarrelling cities and the private armies of merchant lords. Their argument is not foolish. Several harbours remember hunger caused by war between neighbours; mothers have willingly traded local liberties for safe passage. Yet protection has a price, and a force that alone decides the price becomes a master. The Crown's collectors often mistake submission for gratitude. King Eadric's name is invoked in petitions both for redress and for punishment, although the nature of his authority in every city remains disputed.
The League's defenders answer that no distant ruler can know whether an island's well is dry, its harbour wall broken, or its families at feud. They ask for accountable city councils, open charters and the right to withhold tribute. But their city councils answer too readily to the richest merchants, whose ships carry grain and whose money pays the guards. A widow from Lykonia asked what good a free assembly was if she had to sell her vote for bread. The council entered her words into its roll and did nothing else that year.
A third party, neither Crown nor League, meets in scholars' workshops and old shrines. It holds that neither kings nor wealthy citizens own the sea, the rivers or the power beneath the land. Its members study older covenants but disagree on whether the return of lost power would heal anything at all. One faction would destroy every pump; another warns that abrupt destruction can flood a settlement with forces no one has measured. The ordinary boatman must choose before the philosophers finish arguing.